Well, it depends on your preferences as a whole in terms of games because there are quite a lot of them, and it's hard to guess what you like. Personally, I got hooked on horror movies and now I’m reading a selection of the best board games in the horror genre -
https://boardgamesguru.com/best-horror-board-games/ and I’m thinking which option to buy for myself. I would never have thought that such a game can be really scary, but if you play at night, you can describe yourself from fear, to be honest.